| 2022 Overall: 9-2 MWC: 8-1, Co-Champion NCAA Division III Tournament: First Round Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Results | News | Statistics | Roster |
| 2021 Overall: 10-1 MWC: 9-0, Champion NCAA Division III Tournament: First Round Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Results | News | Statistics | Roster |
| 2020-21 Overall: 3-0 Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Results | News | Statistics | Roster |
| 2019 Overall: 7-3 MWC: 4-1, 2nd (North) Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2018 Overall: 6-4 MWC: 4-1, 2nd (South) Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2017 Overall: 8-2 MWC: 4-1, 2nd (South) Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2016 Overall: 8-2 MWC: 6-2, t-3rd Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2015 Overall: 4-6 MWC: 3-2, 3rd (South) Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2014 Overall: 4-6 MWC: 2-3, 4th (South) Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2013 Overall: 8-2 MWC: 7-2, t-2nd Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2012 Overall: 8-2 MWC: 8-1, Co-Champion Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2011 Overall: 3-7 MWC: 3-6, 7th Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2010 Overall: 2-8 MWC: 2-7, t-8th Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2009 Overall: 2-8 MWC: 2-7, t-7th Head Coach: Jim Catanzaro Team Photo | Roster | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2008 Overall: 3-7 MWC: 3-6, 7th Head Coach: Brent Becker Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2007 Overall: 5-5 MWC: 5-4, t-4th Head Coach: Brent Becker Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2006 Overall: 5-5 MWC: 5-4, 5th Head Coach: Brent Becker Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2005 Overall: 4-6 MWC: 3-6, t-7th Head Coach: Brent Becker Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2004 Overall: 8-2 MWC: 7-2, 3rd Head Coach: Chad Eisele Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2003 Overall: 7-3 MWC: 6-3, 3rd Head Coach: Chad Eisele Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2002 Overall: 9-2 MWC: 8-1, Co-Champion NCAA Division III Tournament: First Round Head Coach: Chad Eisele Team Photo | Results | News | Statistics |
| 2001 Overall: 4-6 MWC: 4-4, t-5th Head Coach: Chad Eisele Results | News | Statistics |
| 2000 Overall: 3-7 MWC: 3-6, t-6th Head Coach: Chad Eisele Results | News | Statistics |
| 1999 Overall: 5-5 MWC: 4-5, t-5th Head Coach: Randy Moore Results |
| 1998 Overall: 4-6 MWC: 4-4, 5th Head Coach: Randy Moore Results |
| 1997 Overall: 2-7 MWC: 1-4, 6th (North) Head Coach: Randy Moore Results |
| 1996 Overall: 2-7 MWC: 2-3, 4th (North) Head Coach: Randy Moore Results |
| 1995 Overall: 0-9 MWC: 0-5, 6th (North) Head Coach: Randy Moore Results |
| 1994 Overall: 1-8 MWC: 1-4, t-5th (North) Head Coach: Maury Waugh Results |
| 1993 Overall: 2-7 MCAC: 1-4, 6th (North) Head Coach: Maury Waugh Results |
| 1992 Overall: 3-6 MCAC: 1-4, t-5th (North) Head Coach: Maury Waugh Results |
| 1991 Overall: 2-7 MCAC: 0-4, 5th (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1990 Overall: 1-8 MCAC: 0-6, 5th (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1989 Overall: 1-6 MCAC: 2-4, 3rd (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1988 Overall: 1-8 MCAC: 0-6, 5th (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1987 Overall: 2-6 MCAC: 2-5, t-3rd (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1986 Overall: 5-3 MCAC: 4-3, 2nd (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1985 Overall: 5-4 MCAC: 3-4, t-3rd (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1984 Overall: 6-2 MCAC: 5-2, 3rd (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1983 Overall: 7-2 MCAC: 4-0, 1st (North) MCAC Champions Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1982 Overall: 4-4 MCAC: 1-3, 4th (North) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1981 Overall: 3-5 MCAC: 3-5, t-6th Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1980 Overall: 4-3-1 MCAC: 4-3-1, t-6th Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1979 Overall: 3-5 MCAC: 2-2, t-2nd (Red) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1978 Overall: 5-4 MCAC: 4-0, 1st (Blue) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1977 Overall: 4-4 MCAC: 2-2, 3rd (East) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1976 Overall: 2-6 MCAC: 1-3, t-3rd (East) Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1975 Overall: 2-6 MCAC: 1-6, 9th Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1974 Overall: 2-6 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1973 Overall: 3-4-1 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1972 Overall: 4-3-1 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1971 Season canceled due to insufficient players Head Coach: Mike Dau |
| 1970 Overall: 3-6 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1969 Overall: 2-6 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1968 Overall: 2-7 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1967 Overall: 3-6 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1966 Overall: 2-5 Head Coach: Mike Dau Results |
| 1965 Overall: 5-3 Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1964 Overall: 3-5 Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1963 Overall: 2-4-1 Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1962 Overall: 0-7 CCI: 0-7, 8th Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1961 Overall: 0-8 CCI: 0-6, 7th Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1960 Overall: 4-3-1 CCI: 1-3-1, t-5th Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1959 Overall: 3-5 CCI: 2-5, t-6th Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1958 Overall: 5-3 CCI: 4-3, t-4th Head Coach: Nick Wasylik Results |
| 1957 Overall: 6-2 CCI: 6-1, Co-Champion Head Coach: Walter Lemm Results |
| 1956 Overall: 3-4-1 CCI: 3-3-1, t-4th Head Coach: Alvin Hanke Results |
| 1955 Overall: 3-3-2 CCI: 3-2-1, 4th Head Coach: Alvin Hanke Results |
| 1954 Overall: 3-5 CCI: 3-3, 4th Head Coach: Alvin Hanke Results |
| 1953 Overall: 5-3 CCI: 4-1, 2nd Head Coach: Walter Lemm Results |
| 1952 Overall: 6-1-1 CCI: 3-0-1, Co-Champion Head Coach: Walter Lemm Results |
| 1951 Overall: 3-4-1 CCI: 3-2, t-3rd Head Coach: John Breen Results |
| 1950 Overall: 3-4-1 CCI: 3-2, 4th Head Coach: John Breen Results |
| 1949 Overall: 3-5 CCI: 3-2, 3rd Head Coach: John Breen Results |
| 1948 Overall: 5-3 CCI: 4-1, t-2nd Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1947 Overall: 3-4-1 CCI: 2-2-1, t-5th Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1946 Overall: 3-1 CCI: 3-1, t-2nd Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1945 No team due to World War II |
| 1944 No team due to World War II |
| 1943 No team due to World War II |
| 1942 Overall: 2-4-1 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1941 Overall: 5-1-2 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1940 Overall: 6-0-1 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1939 Overall: 5-2 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1938 Overall: 7-0 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1937 Overall: 3-1-2 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1936 Overall: 4-2-1 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1935 Overall: 3-4 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1934 Overall: 3-4-1 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1933 Overall: 3-3-1 Head Coach: Ralph Jones Results |
| 1932 Overall: 4-3-1 Head Coach: Ira McIntosh Results |
| 1931 Overall: 0-2-4 Head Coach: Ira McIntosh Results |
| 1930 Overall: 5-1-1 Head Coach: Ira McIntosh Results |
| 1929 Overall: 2-5 Little 19: 0-3 Head Coach: Ira McIntosh Results |
| 1928 Overall: 2-4-1 Little 19: 1-1 Head Coach: Floyd L. Brown Results |
| 1927 Overall: 3-2-3 Head Coach: Floyd L. Brown Results |
| 1926 Overall: 2-3-3 Head Coach: Floyd L. Brown Results |
| 1925 Overall: 5-2 Head Coach: Floyd L. Brown Results |
| 1924 Overall: 1-5 Head Coach: Floyd L. Brown Results |
| 1923 Overall: 2-6-1 Head Coach: Ralph Glaze Results |
| 1922 Overall: 3-3-2 Head Coach: Ralph Glaze Results |
| 1921 Overall: 5-3 Head Coach: Ralph Glaze Results |
| 1920 Overall: 5-3 Head Coach: S. Randall Derby Results |
| 1919 Overall: 3-3-2 Head Coach: S. Randall Derby Results |
| 1918 Overall: 0-1 Head Coach: E.J. Mather Results |
| 1917 Overall: 2-5 Head Coach: E.J. Mather Results |
| 1916 Overall: 1-7 Head Coach: E.J. Mather Results |
| 1915 Overall: 2-4 Head Coach: R.W. Thacker Results |
| 1914 Overall: 3-5 Head Coach: Ira T. Carruthers Results |
| 1913 Overall: 5-1-1 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1912 Overall: 5-0-1 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1911 Overall: 5-1-1 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1910 Overall: 5-2 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1909 Overall: 5-1-1 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1908 Overall: 4-1-1 Head Coach: Burt E. Kennedy Results |
| 1907 Overall: 4-1-1 Head Coach: R.E. Brumbaugh Results |
| 1906 Overall: 3-2 Head Coach: James A. Vaughan Results |
| 1905 Overall: 6-5 Head Coach: James A Vaughan Results |
| 1904 Overall: 3-5-1 Head Coach: Clarence Herschberger Results |
| 1903 Overall: 6-1 Head Coach: Clarence Herschberger Results |
| 1902 Overall: 4-4-1 Head Coach: Clarence Herschberger Results |
| 1901 Overall: 9-5 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1900 Overall: 1-0 Head Coach: D.H. Jackson Results |
| 1899 Overall: 4-6-2 Head Coach: D.H. Jackson Results |
| 1898 Overall: 2-1 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1897 Overall: 4-5-1 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1896 Overall: 3-4-1 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1895 Overall: 1-2 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1894 Overall: 3-4 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1893 Overall: 3-2-3 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1892 Overall: 2-3 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1891 Overall: 6-2-1 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1890 Overall: 5-3 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1889 Overall: 1-0 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1888 Overall: 2-2 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
| 1882 Overall: 1-1 Head Coach: Unknown Results |
