| YEAR | RUNNER, CLASS |
| 2022 | Bart Brophy, SO Dean Kousiounelos, SO Johnny Monahan, JR Jake Sharifi, SO Marcelo Camba, FR Joe Maret, SR Lionel Whitehead, SR |
| 2021 | Julián Cano, JR Dean Kousiounelos, FR Matthieu Norcross, SR Christian Reyes, SR Lionel Whitehead, JR |
| 2019 | Nathaniel Bodnar, JR Brandon Johnson, JR Mathieu Norcross, SO Aiden Pratt, SR Christian Reyes, SO Lionel Whitehead, FR |
| 2018 | Christian Aldana, SR Nathaniel Bodnar, SO David Carrillo, SR Nathaniel Kregar, FR Mathieu Norcross, FR Aiden Pratt, JR Christian Reyes, FR Jorge Villanueva, SR |
| 2017 | Christian Aldana, JR Aiden Pratt, SO Jonathan Stern, SR |
| 2016 | Matthew Black, SO Rocco DiMatteo, SR Sintayehu Regassa, SR Jonathan Stern, JR |
| 2015 | Matthew Black, FR Alec Bruns, JR Paul Jones, JR Sintayehu Regassa, JR Jonathan Stern, SO |
| 2014 | Steve Auman, SO Joseph Bortolotti, SO Alec Bruns, FR Thomas Flynn, SR Paul Jones, FR Adnan Meskic, SR |
| 2013 | Thomas Flynn, JR Adnan Meskic, JR Joseph Bartolotti, FR |
| 2012 | Tom Flynn, SO Adnan Meskic, SO |
| 2011 | Yipeng Hu, SO |
| 2010 | Michael Frederick, SR Mills McIlroy, SR Evan Piermont, SR Peter Sullivan, JR |
| 2009 | Max Koenen, JR Mills McIlroy, JR Evan Piermont, JR John Stanescki, JR Peter Sullivan, SO |
| 2008 | Chris Bembynista, SR Evan Piermont, SO Gilbert Reynders, SO |
| 2006 | Chris Bembynista, SO Asa Reynolds, SO James Zender, SO |
| 2005 | Will Pittinos, SR |
| 2004 | Logan Dick, SR Will Pittinos, JR |
| 2003 | Logan Dick, JR Sean O'Connor, SR Will Pittinos, SO |
| 2002 | Rob Bahde, SR Eric Crawley, SR Brandon Johnson, SR Sean O'Connor, JR Logan Dick, SO |
| 2001 | Joe Zemaitis, SR Charles Evans, SR Rob Bahde, JR Eric Crawley, JR Brandon Johnson, JR Erich Urban, SR Sean O'Connor, SO |
| 2000 | Joe Zemaitis, JR Charles Evans, JR Rob Bahde, SO Eric Crawley, SO Brandon Johnson, SO |
| 1999 | Joe Zemaitis, SO |
| 1997 | Chris Leichliter, SR |
