| YEAR | PLAYER, CLASS, POSITION | AWARD |
| 2023 | Elena Chrisman, SR, OF | Second Team All-Region IX (NFCA) |
| 2022 | Josie Klein, SR, OF Hannah Smith, FR, P |
Second Team All-Region IX (NFCA) Third Team All-Region IX (NFCA) |
| 2021 | Carlie Mertz, JR, UT/P | Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2017 | Riley Frisbie, FR, 1B Maria Zepeda, SO, OF |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2016 | Sally Snarski, SR, 1B Jessi Werner, SR, P Alex Hemmer, SR, C Jenny McTague, JR, P Kaleigh Ambrose, SR, 3B |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2015 | Jessi Werner, JR, P Kaleigh Ambrose, JR, 3B Sally Snarski, JR, 1B Alex Hemmer, JR, C |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2014 | Kayla Borgra, JR, OF Jenny McTague, FR, P |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2011 | Ashley Cuthbert, SO, UTIL | Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2010 | Mallory Norton, SR, 3B Tracy Rainey, SR, SS Jordan Ratliff, FR, P |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2009 | Tracy Rainey, JR, SS Mallory Norton, JR, 3B |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2008 | Christy Condon, SR, UTIL Jill Pfund, SO, C |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2007 | Christy Condon, JR, OF Shelby Neill, FR, UTIL Tracy Rainey, FR, SS |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2006 | Ashley Closson, SR, UTIL Lisa Jeziorny, JR, C Melissa Wegner, SR, SS Erin Watts, JR, OF |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2005 | Erin Watts, SO, OF Ashley Closson, JR, UTIL Alissa Mildebrath, SR, 2B Melissa Wegner, JR, SS |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2004 | Kristen Feeney, JR, UTIL Alissa Mildebrath, JR, 2B Leigh Anne Furgerson, SR, P |
Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2003 | Alissa Mildebrath, SO, 2B Robyn Slater, SR, 3B Leigh Anne Furgerson, JR, P Shanon Joselane, SR, 1B |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
| 2002 | Nancy Findeisen, SO, P Jenn Reifenberg, SR, C Alissa Mildebrath, FR, 2B Tina Koludrovic, FR, SS Leigh Anne Furgerson, SO, P |
First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) First Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Second Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) Third Team All-Great Lakes Region (NFCA) |
