| YEAR | PLAYER, CLASS |
| 2022 | Haley Bryant, SR Rebekkah De Kok, SO Grace Franz, JR Mary Gegen, JR Marissa Gulley, SO Lilly Robinson, FR Holland Smits, JR Madison Stevens, SR Izzi Visnjevac, SR Lauren Volk, SO |
| 2021 | Rebekkah DeKok, FR Mary Gegen, SO Marissa Gulley, FR Hannah Kobienia, SR Emilija Matic, FR Abby McKinley, SO Madison Stevens, JR Izzi Visnjevac, JR Lauren Volk, SO |
| 2019 | Isabel Donnelly, JR Olivia Drevs, JR Hannah Hornacek, SR Hannah Nauert, JR Olivia Rhodes, SR Allyson Richards, JR Olivia Smith, JR Madison Stevens, FR Allison Trutna, SR Izzi Visnjevac, FR |
| 2018 | Annika Daley, SR Isabel Donnelly, SO Olivia Drevs, SO Grace Larson, SR Morgen Malte, SR Hannah Nauert, SO Allyson Richards, SO Olivia Smith, SO |
| 2017 | Olivia Grimmer, FR Maxie Mottlowitz, SR Natalie Olson, SR Allyson Richards, FR |
| 2016 | Paige Jespersen, SR Deb Jezuit, FR Rebecca Lynch, JR Morgen Malte, SO Beana Yanovskaya, FR |
| 2015 | Brittany Avonts, JR Brianne Honda, SR Mallory Krzysciak, FR Natalie Literski, SR Morgen Malte, FR |
| 2014 | Kaitlyn Ladao, SR Torie Pasiewicz, SR Brianne Honda, JR Erin Sully, JR Brittany Avonts, SO |
| 2013 | Kaitlyn Ladao, SO Natalie Literski, SO |
| 2012 | Kristen Braun, SR Cori Cooper, SR Courtney Faulstick, SR Molly McCloskey, SR Tia Rupnik, SR Megan Trubich, SR Brooke Perkins, SO Brianne Honda, FR Erin Sully, FR |
| 2011 | Kristen Braun, JR Molly McCloskey, JR Brooke Perkins, FR |
| 2010 | Mandi Mulliner, SR Kristen Braun, SO Cori Cooper, SO |
| 2009 | Megan Fasules, SR Mandi Mulliner, JR |
| 2008 | Ashleigh Martinez, SR Lisa Sturgill, SR Megan Fasules, JR Mandi Mulliner, SO |
| 2007 | Nicole Baich, SR Regina Cyvas, SO Megan Fasules, SO Merissa Martin, SR Ashleigh Martinez, JR Lisa Sturgill, JR |
| 2006 | Nicole Baich, JR Merissa Martin, JR Ashleigh Martinez, SO Lisa Sturgill, SO Synneve Yoder, SO |
| 2005 | Molly Smith, SR Keely Knack, SR Nicole Baich, SO Merissa Martin, SO |
| 2004 | Amy Krueger, SR Andrea Krueger, SR Keely Knack, JR Molly Smith, JR |
| 2003 | Stephanie Metzger, SR Amy Krueger, JR Andrea Krueger, JR Keely Knack, SO Molly Smith, SO |
| 2002 | Stephanie Metzger, JR Amy Krueger, SO Andrea Krueger, SO Abbey Larson, SO |
| 2001 | Angela Lagerman, SR Stephanie Reinboldt, SR Kelly McNiff, JR |
| 2000 | Ashley Moats, SR Amanda Taylor, SR Angela Lagerman, JR Stephanie Reinboldt, JR Kelly McNiff, SO |
| 1999 | Ashley Moats, JR Amanda Taylor, JR Jennifer Hooton, SO Angela Lagerman, SO Stephanie Reinboldt, SO |
| 1998 | Lindsey Hall, JR Ashley Moats, SO Amanda Taylor, SO |
| 1997 | Anna Panighetti, SR Michelle Vandigo, SR Lindsey Hall, SO |
| 1996 | Tanya Lazaro, SR Anna Panighetti, JR Michelle Vandigo, JR |
| 1995 | Anna Panighetti, SO |
| 1991 | Amy Rogers, JR |
| 1990 | Nicole Angeli, SR Amy Rogers, SO |
