| OPPONENT | RECORD | STREAK | LAST MEETING |
| Akron, University of | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 2-3 (1963) |
| Augustana College | 2-3-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/14/16) |
| Aurora University | 18-14-2 | Lost 3 | L, 1-2 (9/18/19) |
| Beloit College | 42-17-1 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (10/4/22) |
| Benedictine University | 15-9-2 | Lost 5 | L, 0-2 (9/9/18) |
| Blackburn | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 3-2 (10/19/62) |
| California Lutheran University | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (9/13/19) |
| Calvin College | 2-3-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-3 (9/2/17) |
| Carleton College | 8-5-2 | Lost 2 | L, 0-2 (9/18/21) |
| Carroll University | 24-10-0 | Won 2 | W, 2-0 (9/5/18) |
| Carthage College | 6-12-2 | Lost 4 | L, 0-5 (10/12/22) |
| Chicago, University of | 22-10-2 | Lost 7 | L, 2-6 (11/11/17) |
| Coe College | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 4-0 (9/10/16) |
| Colorado College | 1-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 1-2 (9/5/21) |
| Concordia University Chicago | 12-0-0 | Won 12 | W, 3-0 (9/12/22) |
| Concordia University Wisconsin | 1-1-0 | Won 1 | W, 1-0 (9/9/17) |
| Cornell College | 9-2-1 | Tied 1 | T, 0-0 (10/15/22) |
| Denison University | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-2 (11/20/65) |
| DePauw University | 1-2-1 | Tie 1 | T, 1-1 (1973) |
| Dominican University | 0-6-0 | Lost 6 | L, 1-3 (9/12/21) |
| Dubuque, University of | 1-0-1 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (9/6/13) |
| DuPage, College of | 0-0-1 | Tie 1 | T, 1-1 (1996) |
| Earlham College | 1-7-1 | Lost 1 | L, 1-8 (10/27/73) |
| Edgewood College | 2-1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (9/14/14) |
| Elmhurst College | 1-3-1 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/10/22) |
| Eureka College | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 11-0 (9/2/12) |
| Finlandia University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 13-2 (10/17/10) |
| Fontbonne University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 5-3 (9/13/15) |
| Grinnell College | 30-11-4 | Won 2 | W, 2-1 (11/5/22) |
| Gustavus Adolphus College | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/3/22) |
| Hope College | 6-3-1 | Lost 2 | L, 0-1 (9/1/17) |
| Illinois College | 21-4-1 | Won 12 | W, 2-1 (10/8/22) |
| Illinois-Chicago, University of | 2-2-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-2 (10/19/66) |
| Illinois Institute of Technology | 12-2-0 | Won 1 | W, 6-2 (10/25/16) |
| Illinois Wesleyan University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (9/7/19) |
| Judson College | 4-5-0 | Lost 4 | L, 1-7 (10/25/99) |
| Kalamazoo College | 0-1-1 | Tied 1 | T, 2-2 (9/18/22) |
| Kendall College | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 1-0 (10/30/01) |
| Kenyon College | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 3-4 (1967) |
| Knox College | 24-8-0 | Won 2 | W, 4-3 (2OT) (11/4/22) |
| Lake Forest Academy | 3-0-0 | Won 3 | W, 3-0 (1963) |
| Lawrence University | 38-14-4 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (9/24/22) |
| Lewis University | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-9 (9/26/73) |
| Luther College | 0-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 0-3 (9/4/22) |
| Macalester College | 0-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 0-3 (9/9/16) |
| MacMurray College | 5-5-4 | Lost 2 | L, 1-2 (1980) |
| Maranatha Baptist Bible College | 1-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (10/1/07) |
| Marian University | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 2-1 (9/10/11) |
| Maryknoll Seminary | 3-2-3 | Won 2 | W, 5-1 (10/7/70) |
| Millikin University | 1-1-0 | Won 1 | W, 3-0 (9/28/11) |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | 4-2-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/13/13) |
| Monmouth College | 20-4-3 | Won 7 | W, 3-1 (10/1/22) |
| Moody Bible Institute | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 5-1 (9/3/15) |
| Mount Mercy College | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 8-1 (9/5/03) |
| National College of Education | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 1-4 (8/20/89) |
| North Central College | 7-10-1 | Lost 3 | L, 0-1 (10/14/22) |
| Northern Illinois University | 4-4-1 | Lost 4 | L, 0-2 (9/29/79) |
| North Park University | 9-9-1 | Lost 7 | L, 0-5 (9/20/22) |
| Northwestern University | 0-1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/26/84) |
| Notre Dame, University of | 0-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 2-3 (1963) |
| Oberlin College | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (11/19/65) |
| Occidental College | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (9/15/19) |
| Ohio Northern University | 0-0-1 | Tied 1 | T, 2-2 (2OT) (8/30/19) |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (1966) |
| Olivet College | 0-0-1 | Tied 1 | T, 1-1 (OT) (9/14/18) |
| Pacific Lutheran University | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-4 (9/4/21) |
| Principia College | 2-1-1 | Tie 1 | T, 1-1 (11/3/73) |
| Quincy College | 0-1-0 | Lost 1 | L, 0-1 (1964) |
| Ripon College | 45-13-1 | Tied 1 | T, 0-0 (9/27/22) |
| Rockford College | 20-11-3 | Won 4 | W, 8-1 (9/4/11) |
| Roosevelt University | 2-1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (9/16/87) |
| St. Mary's University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (9/2/11) |
| St. Norbert College | 25-13-4 | Lost 1 | L, 1-2 (11/8/19) |
| St. Olaf College | 1-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 1-8 (11/12/22) |
| St. Thomas, University of | 0-3-0 | Lost 3 | L, 0-4 (9/8/18) |
| Trinity International University | 18-3-3 | Won 3 | W, 2-1 (9/7/17) |
| Willamette University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (2OT) (8/29/14) |
| Wabash College | 5-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 1-3 (1973) |
| Webster University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 3-2 (9/11/15) |
| Westminster University | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 3-1 (9/2/18) |
| Wheaton College | 6-35-1 | Lost 16 | L, 1-3 (9/7/22) |
| Wisconsin Lutheran College | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 4-1 (9/16/18) |
| Wisconsin, University of | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 5-1 (1964) |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee, University of | 0-2-0 | Lost 2 | L, 1-6 (10/26/77) |
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh, University of | 0-4-0 | Lost 4 | L, 1-5 (10/17/99) |
| Wisconsin-Parkside, University of | 6-5-2 | Lost 3 | L, 0-1 (10/10/84) |
| Wisconsin-Platteville, University of | 2-0-0 | Won 2 | W, 3-1 (10/1/03) |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater, University of | 10-9-1 | Lost 2 | L, 2-3 (9/28/15) |
| Wooster, College of | 1-0-0 | Won 1 | W, 2-1 (1967) |
