| YEAR | PLAYER/COACH, CLASS | AWARD |
| 2022 | Elliot Hull, JR Sam Bickersteth, JR Elliot Hull, JR Teddy Kolesnikov, SR Szymon Mocarski, JR |
MWC Elite 20 Award College Sports Communicators Academic All-District® College Sports Communicators Academic All-District® College Sports Communicators Academic All-District® College Sports Communicators Academic All-District® |
| 2020-21 | Joao Godoy, SR Jan Roessler, SR Joao Godoy, SR Joao Godoy, SR |
CoSIDA First Team Academic All-District® CoSIDA First Team Academic All-District® CoSIDA Third Team Academic All-American® Midwest Conference Men's and Mixed Sports Athlete of the Year |
| 2019 | Gaston Aubert, SR Gaston Aubert, SR Gaston Aubert, SR Gaston Aubert, SR |
CoSIDA First Team Academic All-District® CoSIDA Third Team Academic All-American® United Soccer Coaches Second Team Acacemic All-North/Central Region United Soccer Coaches Third Team Scholar All-America |
| 2016 | Nipun Chauhan, SO | Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award |
| 2013 | Chris Bergmann Mahir Mameledzija, SR Mahir Mameledzija, SR Mahir Mameledzija, SR Team |
Midwest Conference Coach of the Year Capital One Academic All-American of the Year® Capital One Academic All-America® First Team Capital One Academic All-District® NSCAA Team Academic Award |
| 2012 | Chris Bergmann Mahir Mameledzija, JR Mahir Mameledzija, JR |
Midwest Conference Coach of the Year Capital One Academic All-America® First Team Capital One Academic All-District® |
| 2011 | Mahir Mameledzija, SO | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2000 | Ed Kositzki | Midwest Conference Coach of the Year |
| 1997 | Eric Kendig, SR | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1996 | Eric Kendig, JR Ed Kositzki |
Junior Scholar/Athlete Award Midwest Conference Coach Of the Year |
| 1995 | T.R. Bell, SR Eric Kendig, SO Ed Kositzki |
Nicholas Wasylik Award Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award Midwest Conference Coach of the Year |
| 1994 | Eric Kendig, FR | Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1993 | Jon Parkman, JR Tom Larsson, SO |
Junior Scholar/Athlete Award Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1991 | Dan Bracken, SR Jon Parkman, FR |
Nicholas Wasylik Award Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1990 | Frank Salvoni, SR | Nicholas Wasylik Award |
| 1988 | Marcus Jurema, SO | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1987 | Marcus Jurema, FR | Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1986 | Rob Cummisford, FR | Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1985 | Ralph Kunzmann, SR John Burk, JR |
Nicholas Wasylik Award Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1984 | Fred Senft, SR | All-Midwest Region Team |
| 1978 | Glenn Pearson, FR | NSCAA All-Illinois Team |
| 1976 | Dave Weisbecker, JR Doug Moorad, SR Humphrey Mosenge, SR Dave Weisbecker, JR |
NSCAA All-Illinois Team NSCAA All-Illinois Team NSCAA All-Illinois Team NAIA All-District 20 Team |
| 1975 | Humphrey Mosenge, JR Jeff Miller, SR Doug Moorad, JR |
NSCAA All-Illinois Team NSCAA All-Illinois Team NSCAA All-Illinois Team |
| 1972 | Jeff Miller, FR Meade Thayer, JR |
NAIA Second Team All-District 20 NAIA Second Team All-District 20 |
| 1970 | Bryan Porto, SR | NAIA First Team All-District 20 |
| 1969 | Ben Murray, JR Bryan Porto, JR |
NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA First Team All-District 20 |
| 1968 | Ben Murray, SO Bryan Porto, SO Ben Murray, SO Bryan Porto, SO |
NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA First Team All-District 20 NSCAA Second Team All-Midwest Region NSCAA Honorable Mention All-Midwest Region |
| 1967 | Bryan Porto, FR Phil Lee, N/A Phil Zoller, SR Mike Chapman, SR |
NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA Second Team All-District 20 NAIA Second Team All-District 20 NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 1966 | Robert Ayres, SR Ben Egel, SR Montgomery Byers, SR Mike Chapman, JR Dick Driscoll, FR Rick Ford, FR |
NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA Honorable Mention All-District 20 NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Second Team NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Second Team NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Second Team |
| 1965 | Robert Ayres, JR Derrick Gondwe, SR Robert Ayres, JR Derrick Gondwe, SR Gene Goss, SR Gene Goss, SR Derrick Gondwe, SR Dick Triptow |
NSCAA All-Midwest Region Team NSCAA All-Midwest Region Team NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA First Team All-District 20 NAIA First Team All-District 20 NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Team NAIA District 20 Coach of the Year |
| 1964 | Sandy Hewat, SO Gene Goss, JR |
NAIA All-District 20 NAIA All-District 20 |
| 1963 | Al Gaudio, FR Robert Ayres, FR |
NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Mid-East Regional All-Tournament Team |
