| YEAR | CAPTAINS |
| 2022 | Javan Ah Quin, Justin Albee, Alex Bendler, A.J. Jackson, Tre Stewart |
| 2021 | Connor Cahill, A.J. Jackson, Dominic Johnson, Jamari Tansmore, Cooper Tomlin |
| 2020-21 | Jamari Tansmore, Matt Leonard |
| 2019 | Michael Bounds, John Colasacco, Bill Degnan, Johnny Laponte, Jordan McInerney |
| 2018 | Jagan Cleary, Chris Edomwande, Johnny Laponte, Ethan Sheirer, Charlie Timmerman |
| 2017 | Tim Finucane, R.J. Pompey, Tom Steen, Joey Valdivia |
| 2016 | R.J. Pompey, Brendan Power, Charlie Quinn, Tom Steen |
| 2015 | Adam Bernstein, Luke Capone, Pat Clark, Brendan Power, Austin Van Meter |
| 2014 | Bryan Feltman, Joey Kropp, John Preston, Ramel Samuel |
| 2013 | Jordan Cruz, Mike Lewis, Tom Mitchell, Jake Rotkvich |
| 2012 | Al Mitchell, Jake Rotkvich, Pete Scaffidi |
| 2011 | Luke Butts, Casey Flynn, Salvador Perales |
| 2010 | Anthony Garetto, Brock Stenberg, Steven Yena |
| 2009 | Dan Carter, Jaron Eanes, Chad Zimborski |
| 2008 | Matt Lawler, Sam Kotler, Chris Tossing |
| 2007 | Jeff Ziemnik, Ed Kidd |
| 2006 | Lee Fabiatos, Keith Hanson, Louis Bertuca |
| 2005 | Keith Hanson, Ryan Gallegos, A.J. Rodino |
| 2004 | Nick Hildreth, David Bleitner, Troy Paulsen |
| 2003 | Pat Gillihan, Don Lackey, Tom Starnicky |
| 2002 | Casey Urlacher, Pat Dunne, Mike Fitzgerald |
| 2001 | Casey Urlacher, Ryan Paulsen, Pat Dunne |
| 2000 | Pat Dunne, Andy O'Hara, Steve Halle |
| 1999 | Dustin Cassady, Tom Dranger, Bernie Perconti |
| 1998 | Blake Deavers, Tom Dranger, Simon Kotlyar, Tim Orszula |
| 1997 | Corey Honore, Phil Persoon, Ryan Shoemaker |
| 1996 | Bob Fulbright, Phil Persoon, Brennan Young |
| 1995 | John Klasen, Cordell Larkin, Steve Westfall, Brennan Young |
| 1994 | Eric Abrahamson, Matt Ferrari, John Klasen, Dave Mills |
| 1993 | Eric Abrahamson, Butch Bendery, Jim DeLisa, Dave Hansen |
| 1992 | Bill Brown, Mo Butler, Jim DeLisa |
| 1991 | Joel Forney, Ken Ottaviano, Chris Walsh |
| 1990 | Colin Barbera, Gary Francis |
| 1989 | Jeff Griffith, Steve Pape, Bill Winkler |
| 1988 | Ed Bohan, Muriel Glemaud, Sandy Pahlman |
| 1987 | Wade Gritt, Chris Martin |
| 1986 | Nick Ippolito, Jeff Jatis, Joe Whalen |
| 1985 | Patrick Horne, Dan Zeller |
| 1984 | Joe Sullivan |
| 1983 | Bob Shaw, John Kavanagh |
| 1982 | Joe Bopp, Bob Shaw |
| 1981 | Mike Santacaterina, Steve Savage, Tom Wessel, Ray Hagen |
| 1980 | Ed Pluchar, Phil Lombardo, Peter Magrini |
| 1979 | Bart Tiernan, Peter Magrini |
| 1978 | Bill Bremer, Ron Pankau, Tony Wall |
| 1977 | Ken Addison, George Latto, Andy Livingston |
| 1976 | Dan Catanzaro |
| 1975 | N/A |
| 1974 | T. VonBurskirk |
| 1973 | B. Kelliher |
| 1972 | B. Kelliher |
| 1971 | Did not field a team (insufficient numbers). |
| 1970 | Larry Deetjen |
| 1969 | N/A |
| 1968 | Mike DeRahm, Tom Woodard |
| 1967 | John Wyatt |
| 1966 | James Cartier, Richard Kolowski |
| 1965 | Bill Peery |
| 1964 | Pete Wood |
| 1963 | Ron Matray |
| 1962 | Ken Landstrom |
| 1961 | Bob Craig |
| 1960 | Glenn Walters |
| 1959 | J. Foster, J. Hartford |
| 1958 | Dave Parker |
| 1957 | James Borre |
| 1956 | Dan Herz, Ed Williams |
| 1955 | Jim Hisler |
| 1954 | Robert Burns |
| 1953 | Dennis Johnson, Charles Walsh |
| 1952 | Don Pack, Roger Siuda |
| 1951 | Jack Cassidy |
| 1950 | George Evans |
| 1949 | George Kerrihard, R. Swanson |
| 1948 | George Gutnik |
| 1947 | Jerome "Mike" Powers |
| 1946 | Pete Schmit |
| 1945 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1944 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1943 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1942 | William "Dutch" Ebner |
| 1941 | Floyd "Duke" Gates |
| 1940 | Joe Koss |
| 1939 | R. Peterson |
| 1938 | John Biolo |
| 1937 | R. Schamber |
| 1936 | Evert Larson |
| 1935 | G. Niemeyer |
| 1934 | Bob Bade |
| 1933 | Gunnar Erickson |
| 1932 | John Crook |
| 1931 | Pete Stralko |
| 1930 | Faust "Frost" Ferzacca |
| 1929 | L. Stang |
| 1928 | N/A |
| 1927 | R. Bjorklund |
| 1926 | H. Flancher |
| 1925 | F. Priestman |
| 1924 | R. Folgate |
| 1923 | M. Solberg |
| 1922 | O. Jackson |
| 1921 | R. Russell |
| 1920 | R. Russell |
| 1919 | D. Woods |
| 1918 | N/A |
| 1917 | N/A |
| 1916 | B. Pierce |
| 1915 | M.A. Gray |
| 1914 | E.G. Krueger |
| 1913 | F.A. Dunsmore |
| 1912 | R.J. McKee |
| 1911 | B.A. West |
| 1910 | J.C. Paskins |
| 1909 | E.J. Mather |
| 1908 | E.J. Berkheuser |
| 1907 | L.D. Callahan |
| 1906 | C.C. Gibbs |
| 1905 | F.F. McCrea |
| 1904 | N.T. Yeomans |
| 1903 | Fermar T. Black |
| 1902 | Eugene S. Hann |
| 1901 | Daniel McCarter |
| 1900 | Fred C. Carstons |
| 1899 | Gordon Campbell |
| 1898 | N/A |
| 1897 | W.P. Jackson |
| 1896 | W.F. Jackson |
| 1895 | G.W. Sager, R.O. Stoops |
| 1894 | Fred A. Hayner |
| 1893 | Fred A. Hayner |
| 1892 | N.B.W. Galley |
| 1891 | N.B.W. Galley |
| 1890 | John Steele |
| 1889 | N/A |
| 1888 | N/A |
