| YEAR | PLAYER/COACH | AWARD |
| 2022 | Doug Antonucci, SR, ST Damon Bonds, SR, KR Dante Esposito, SR, DB Alex Bendler, SR, DL Trenton Brail, JR, DB |
First Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Second Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Second Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Third Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Third Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) |
| 2021 | A.J. Jackson, JR, KR Dante Esposito, JR, DB Anthony DerManulian, SR, OL Danny Baker, JR, ST |
First Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) First Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Second Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) Third Team All-Region 5 (D3football.com) |
| 2020-21 | Kobee Marion, JR, DB | Second Team All-Region (D3football.com) |
| 2019 | Jordan McInerney, SR, DL A.J. Jackson, FR, KR Danny Baker, FR, ST |
First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) Third Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2017 | Joey Valdivia, SR, RB | First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2016 | Alex Pasiewicz, SR, RET Joey Valdivia, JR, RB R.J. Pompey, JR, ST |
First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) First Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2014 | Pat Clark, JR, DB | Second Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2013 | Ed Dobernig, SR, DB | Second Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2011 | Luke Butts, SR, DB | Third Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2006 | Keith Hanson, SR, DB Keith Hanson, SR, DB |
Third Team All-West Region (D3football.com) Honorable Mention All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 2005 | Keith Hanson, SR, DB Jeff Huebner, SR, WR Keith Hanson, SR, DB |
Second Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) Second Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) Third Team All-West Region (D3football.com) |
| 2004 | David Bleitner, SR, DL Drew Holman, SR, DB |
First Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) First Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 2003 | David Bleitner, JR, DL | Second Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 2002 | Casey Urlacher, SR, LB | First Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 2001 | Casey Urlacher, JR, LB | Third Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 2000 | Casey Urlacher, SO, LB | Third Team All-West Region (Football Gazette) |
| 1999 | Bernie Perconti, SR, LB | All-West Region Team (Football Gazette) |
