| YEAR | NAME | AWARD |
| 2022-23 | Women's Team Violet Anderson Amelie Andres Caprice Kalvelage Helena Blumenau Women's Team |
Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Newcomer of the Year Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award Second-Team Scholar All-America (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2021-22 | Women's Team Men's Team Ally McCarthy Graeme Witte Vadim Tashlitsky Women's Team Men's Team |
Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Midwest Conference Women's Newcomer of the Year Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2020-21 | Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team Men's Team |
Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2019-20 | Violet Anderson Graeme Witte Vadim Tashlitsky Men's Team Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team Alec Pittman |
Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Honorable Mention Scholar All-America (CSCAA) |
| 2018-19 | Heath Ogawa Lizzie Johns Heath Ogawa Nathan Lightman Men's Team Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Men's Diver of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Year NCAA Division III Men's Diver of the Year (CSCAA) NCAA Division III Men's Diving Coach of the Year (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2017-18 | Heath Ogawa Heath Ogawa Men's Team Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Men's Diver of the Year NCAA Division III Men's Diver of the Year (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2016-17 | Heath Ogawa Virgil Thomas Men's Team Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Men's Diver of the Year Nicholas J. Wasylik Award Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2015-16 | Women's Team Men's Team Women's Team |
Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2014-15 | Christina Pekar Sam Freedberg Victoria Karker Vadim Tashlitsky Women's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Meet Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Meet Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Meet Midwest Conference Men's Coach of the Year Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2013-14 | Christina Pekar Men's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Meet Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2012-13 | Becky Shaak Becky Shaak Sam Gardner Alex Marks Kelsie Miller Sarah Pekar Garr Punnett Christina Pekar Vadim Tashlitsky Vadim Tashlitsky Men's Team Women's Team Women's Team |
Midwest Conference Woman of the Year Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Meet Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year College Swimming Coaches Association of America Coach of Excellence Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) |
| 2011-12 | Becky Shaak Becky Shaak Sam Gardner Vadim Tashlitsky Sam Gardner Matt Perry Women's Team Women's Team Alexis Yusim |
Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Meet Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Meet Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Scholar All-America Team Honorable Mention (CSCAA) Fall Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Spring Scholar All-America Team (CSCAA) Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2010-11 | Vadim Tashlitsky Vadim Tashlitsky |
Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year American Swimming Coaches Association Coach of Excellence |
| 2009-10 | Alex Marks Becky Shaak Vadim Tashlitsky Vadim Tashlitsky |
Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Men's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year |
| 2008-09 | David Ristau | Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2007-08 | Maggie Rezac Maggie Rezac Maggie Rezac Maggie Rezac Michael Ojdana Joey Sun Maggie Rezac |
Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Year First Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) Third Team Academic All-American College Division (CoSIDA) Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award Nicholas J. Wasylik Award |
| 2006-07 | Maggie Rezac Maggie Rezac |
Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Year Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2005-06 | Kendall Swett Susan Bromberg Chelsea Bueter Kendall Swett Maggie Rezac Alexandra Hales |
NCAA Div. III Women's Diver of the Year (CSCAA) NCAA Div. III Women's Diving Coach of the Year (CSCAA) Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Year Second Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2004-05 | Chelsea Bueter Maggie Rezac Alexandra Hales |
Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Diver of the Year Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2003-04 | Chelsea Bueter Chelsea Bueter Alexandra Hales |
Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year ISA Female College Swimmer of the Year Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2001-02 | Joe Zemaitis | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2000-01 | Jie Li Joe Zemaitis |
Midwest Conference Swimmer of the Year Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1999-00 | Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Randi Estes Kari Shuenke Joe Zemaitis |
CSCAA Academic All-American Second Team GTE Academic All-American Illinois All-State selection Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Co-Women's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Co-Women's Swimmer of the Year Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1998-99 | Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Rob Edgell |
CSCAA Academic All-American Third Team GTE Academic All-American Illinois All-State selection CSCAA Academic All-American |
| 1997-98 | Rob Edgell Tom Burton Tom Burton |
Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Men's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year |
| 1996-97 | Rob Edgell Rob Edgell Tobi Limke Tom Burton Tom Burton |
Midwest Conference Swimmer of the Year Illinois All-State selection Midwest Conference Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Men's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year |
| 1995-96 | Tom Burton Tobi Limke |
State of Illinois Women's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year |
| 1994-95 | Tom Burton Tom Burton Dan Tarkowski Tobi Limke Brian Garcia Jeff Johnson |
Midwest Conference Men's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Year Midwest Conference Women's Swimmer of the Year Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Nicholas J. Wasylik Award |
| 1993-94 | Dan Tarkowski | Midwest Conference Men's Swimmer of the Year |
| 1992-93 | Maureen Gallagher | Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1991-92 | Alison Freund | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1987-88 | Matthew Brown | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1986-87 | Skip Cook Nancy Dryden |
State of Illinois Women's Coach of the Year State of Illinois Women's Swimmer of the Year |
| 1984-85 | Philip Klinkner Michael Hanlon |
Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1982-83 | Philip Klinkner | Sophomore Letterman's Award |
| 1981-82 | Philip Klinkner Kathryn Llerandi |
Freshman Letterman's Award Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1980-81 | Kathryn Llerandi | Sophomore Letterman's Award |
| 1978-79 | Barbara Lubben | Sophomore Letterman's Award |
| 1977-78 | Barbara Lubben | Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1974-75 | Janet Wagner | Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1973-74 | Laurie Finke | Senior Letterman's Award |
