| YEAR | PLAYER | AWARD |
| 2023 | Brendan Herbert Trip Gaston Jack Gillard Conor Murphy Connor Tartaglione Simon Colby Brendan Herbert Bobby Ojascastro Bode Rubright Andrew Widlar John Casey Winston Stock |
MLC Rookie of the Year First Team All-MLC First Team All-MLC First Team All-MLC First Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Honorable Mention All-MLC MLC All-Sportsmanship Team |
| 2022 | Conor Murphy John Casey Jack Langworthy Henry Baizer Luke Bowers Connor Tartaglione Caden Elias |
First Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Second Team All-MLC Honorable Mention All-MLC Honorable Mention All-MLC Honorable Mention All-MLC MLC All-Sportsmanship Team |
