| 5K TIME | RUNNER | DATE | MEET |
| 18:57 | Katie Snowden | 10/29/05 | Midwest Conference Championships (Grinnell) |
| 19:04 | Katie Snowden | 10/14/06 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:07.7 | Kristen Whitney | 9/13/14 | Knight Invitational (Calvin) |
| 19:14 | Shanna Palmer | 9/28/96 | Carthage Invitational |
| 19:21 | Sarah Peluse | 9/25/10 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:23c | Shanna Palmer | 10/19/96 | Division-III State Meet (Monmouth) |
| 19:25 | Leann Kimmons | 10/14/06 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:28 | Katie Snowden | 9/30/06 | Sean Earl Lakefront Invitational (Loyola Chicago) |
| 19:29.10 | Sarah Peluse | 9/26/09 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:31 | Shanna Palmer | 10/11/96 | Benedictine Invitational |
| 19:37 | Katie Snowden | 11/1/03 | Midwest Conference Championships (Lake Forest) |
| 19:37.7 | Kristen Whitney | 9/12/15 | Knight Invitational (Calvin) |
| 19:40 | Michelle Kendrick | 9/28/96 | Carthage Invitational |
| 19:46 | Katie Snowden | 10/16/04 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:47 | Leann Kimmons | 10/29/05 | Midwest Conference Championships (Grinnell) |
| 19:48 | Katie Snowden | 10/15/05 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:48.2 | Yaneli Guajardo | 9/22/17 | Brissman-Lundeen Invitational (Augustana) |
| 19:48.5 | Madeline Morland | 9/6/19 | Vic Godfrey Open (UW-Parkside) |
| 19:52.7 | Cassie Lira | 9/3/16 | Tom Barry Invitational (St. Norbert) |
| 19:53 | Katie Snowden | 10/11/03 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:53.1 | Yaneli Guajardo | 9/6/19 | Vic Godfrey Open (UW-Parkside) |
| 19:54 | Ryann Freeman | 9/26/09 | Forester Invitational |
| 19:54.80 | Michelle Murillo | 11/7/98 | Midwest Conference Championships (Beloit) |
| 19:55.6 | Yaneli Guajardo | 9/2/17 | Tom Barry Invitational (St. Norbert) |
| 19:57 | Katie Snowden | 9/16/06 | Midwest Collegiate Open (UW-Parkside) |
c = converted 3-mile time
Current team members are listed in bold italics.