| YEAR | PLAYER | AWARD |
| 2022-23 | Hannah Turnage Willow Poppleton |
All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2021-22 | Olyvia Opsahl Marissa Gebauer Hannah Turnage Sophia Chapman |
All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2020-21 | Jordan Trapp | All-NCHA |
| 2019-20 | Sydney Simone Jordan Trapp Karya Dean |
All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2018-19 | Amy Budde Olyvia Opsahl |
All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2017-18 | Olivia Spellmire Olivia Spellmire Kayla Griffith Amy Budde Lexi Morgan Megan Lyke Jordan Trapp |
NCHA Player of the Year All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2016-17 | Amy Budde Olivia Spellmire Kayla Griffith Julia Unterseher Jacque Rogers Lexi Morgan Sydney Simone Julia Unterseher Jacque Rogers |
All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team NCHA All-Freshman Team NCHA All-Freshman Team NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2015-16 | Michelle Greeneway Michelle Greeneway Olivia Spellmire Alex Stensland Kayla Griffith Allie Carter Amy Budde |
NCHA Player of the Year All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2014-15 | Michelle Greeneway Morgan Pope Alex Stensland Kayla Griffith Kayla Griffith |
All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA NCHA All-Freshman Team |
| 2013-14 | Michelle Greeneway Michelle Greeneway Morgan Pope Alex Stensland |
NCHA Player of the Year All-NCHA All-NCHA All-NCHA |
| 2012-13 | Michelle Greeneway Melissa Paluch Sarah Gilbride Stacey Dierking Michelle Greeneway Melissa Paluch |
First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA NCHA All-Rookie Team NCHA All-Rookie Team |
| 2011-12 | Angie Chronis Kim Herring Jenna Brankin Jenna Brankin |
First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA NCHA All-Rookie Team |
| 2010-11 | Melissa Kravich | Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2009-10 | Kim Herring Kim Herring Courtney Bean Jamie Sauer Lynn Switaj Melissa Kravich Alyssa Wintermute |
NCHA Player of the Year First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2008-09 | Courtney Bean Jamie Sauer Melissa Kravich Kim Herring |
First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2007-08 | Courtney DeHoey Kerry Gotowka |
First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2006-07 | Courtney DeHoey Allison Rushing Sally Bevis Laura Wilson |
First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2005-06 | Allison Rushing Sally Bevis Courtney DeHoey Dayna Kanis Laura Wilson Lil Caligiuri Darby McGrath |
First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2004-05 | Lil Caligiuri Sally Bevis Laura Wilson |
Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2002-03 | Robyn Slater Theresa Taylor Lil Caligiuri Lindsey Wild |
First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2001-02 | Robyn Slater Lydia Groskin Lindsey Wild |
First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |
| 2000-01 | Robyn Slater Theresa Taylor Aja Dailey |
First Team All-NCHA First Team All-NCHA Honorable Mention All-NCHA |