| OPPONENT | RECORD | STREAK | LAST MEETING |
| Alma College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 65-71 (12/18/15) |
| Alverno College | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 77-35 (12/19/21) |
| Augustana College | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 65-63 (11/17/01) |
| Aurora University | 8-6 | Won 2 | W, 76-47 (11/25/02) |
| Austin College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 45-62 (11/27/98) |
| Barat College | 3-0 | Won 3 | W, 57-43 (2/6/79) |
| Beloit College | 53-22 | Won 10 | W, 97-88 (ot) (2/4/23) |
| Benedictine University | 11-12 | Lost 3 | L, 48-63 (11/27/18) |
| Bluffton College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 82-62 (11/21/97) |
| Bowdoin College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 69-77 (11/18/00) |
| Buena Vista University | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 78-63 (11/17/12) |
| California Lutheran University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 65-71 (12/20/10) |
| California-San Diego, University of | 1-2 | Won 1 | W, 79-65 (12/29/96) |
| Calvin College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 42-68 (3/1/00) |
| Cardinal Stritch College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 67-26 (2/7/76) |
| Carleton College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 92-57 (11/26/90) |
| Carroll University | 33-21 | Lost 4 | L, 46-66 (2/20/16) |
| Carthage College | 6-18 | Lost 9 | L, 62-70 (11/22/22) |
| Central College (IA) | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 71-82 (3/2/94) |
| Chicago, University of | 12-19 | Lost 5 | L, 63-85 (11/8/18) |
| Chicago State University | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 39-74 (2/18/83) |
| Christopher Newport University (VA) | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 62-65 (2/18/06) |
| Clarke College | 2-1 | Lost 1 | L, 58-65 (11/26/94) |
| Coe College | 4-0 | Won 4 | W, 52-51 (1/25/97) |
| Concordia University Chicago | 17-8 | Won 14 | W, 57-46 (11/17/07) |
| Concordia University Wisconsin | 2-3 | Lost 1 | L, 37-81 (2/20/21) |
| Cornell College | 15-13 | Lost 4 | L, 68-75 (1/7/23) |
| Denison University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 55-69 (12/30/12) |
| DePaul University | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 60-99 (1977) |
| Dominican University | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 82-80 (2/23/21) |
| DuPage College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 64-49 (1978) |
| Edgewood College | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 72-78 (11/16/18) |
| Elmhurst College | 5-3 | Won 4 | W, 78-73 (11/16/07) |
| Elms College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 75-29 (12/29/02) |
| Finlandia University | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 72-65 (12/19/10) |
| Fontbonne University | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 64-78 (1/9/23) |
| Fort Sheridan | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 100-51 (2/3/82) |
| Geneseo College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 53-58 (12/28/93) |
| George Fox University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 43-92 (12/21/14) |
| George Williams College | 3-2 | Lost 1 | L, 51-74 (1/31/83) |
| Greenville College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 33-64 (1/28/80) |
| Grinnell College | 39-12 | Lost 2 | L, 75-78 (2/18/23) |
| Gustavus Adolphus | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 64-56 (12/28/96) |
| Hope College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 57-95 (12/19/15) |
| Illinois College | 31-23 | Won 1 | W, 88-77 (ot) (2/11/23) |
| Illinois Institute of Technology | 6-0 | Won 6 | W, 87-36 (11/19/18) |
| Illinois State JV | 1-2 | Won 1 | W, 80-54 (1/16/81) |
| Illinois Wesleyan University | 6-1 | Won 1 | W, 60-59 (11/22/05) |
| Johns Hopkins University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 59-67 (11/29/03) |
| Joliet J.C. | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 52-47 (2/2/80) |
| Judson College | 7-3 | Won 4 | W, 77-66 (11/20/99) |
| Kean College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 59-74 (12/31/08) |
| Kenyon College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 50-63 (12/29/16) |
| Knox College | 43-17 | Lost 6 | L, 59-68 (1/21/23) |
| Lakeland College | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 85-64 (1/24/89) |
| La Verne, University of | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 92-102 (12/29/12) |
| Lawrence University | 59-16 | Won 1 | W, 59-47 (2/8/23) |
| Loras College | 2-1 | Lost 1 | L, 78-91 (11/17/18) |
| Loyola University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 46-79 (1/29/80) |
| Luther College | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 95-89 (ot) (12/18/22) |
| Macalester University | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 75-40 (11/22/02) |
| Marian University | 3-0 | Won 3 | W, 85-52 (11/12/19) |
| Marquette University | 0-2 | Lost 2 | L, 43-60 (2/13/76) |
| Martin Luther College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 72-79 (11/12/22) |
| Maryville | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 65-61 (3/2/07) |
| McMurry University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 67-73 (12/19/10) |
| Millikin University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 49-80 (12/9/08) |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | 9-5 | Won 1 | W, 70-60 (11/15/22) |
| Monmouth College | 40-18 | Won 1 | W, 80-66 (1/25/23) |
| Moravian College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 84-81 (12/28/93) |
| Morningside College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 61-99 (12/20/19) |
| Mount Mary University | 5-0 | Won 5 | W, 83-64 (1/31/23) |
| Mount Marty College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 63-82 (12/21/18) |
| Mundelein Seminary College | 3-2 | Lost 1 | L, 55-89 (11/20/87) |
| National College of Education | 2-1 | Won 1 | W, 104-77 (11/17/90) |
| North Central College | 12-4 | Won 1 | W, 75-67 (11/18/17) |
| North Park University | 11-8 | Won 7 | W, 54-41 (11/21/08) |
| Northeastern Illinois | 5-4 | Won 2 | W, 77-60 (1990) |
| Northwestern University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 48-49 (3/6/76) |
| Ohio Northern University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 48-67 (11/16/12) |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 55-67 (2/28/01) |
| Olivet Nazerene College | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 74-42 (12/14/79) |
| Point Loma Nazarene University | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 68-66 (1/3/90) |
| Puget Sound, University of | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 61-56 (12/30/99) |
| Ripon College | 38-28 | Lost 11 | L, 76-78 (2/14/23) |
| Rockford College | 8-3 | Won 5 | W, 71-50 (11/20/10) |
| Rosary College | 5-1 | Won 3 | W, 89-87 (12/8/88) |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 61-65 (2ot) (12/30/08) |
| Scranton, University of | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 59-79 (12/28/99) |
| St. Francis | 2-5 | Lost 1 | L, 43-83 (1/19/82) |
| St. Mary's University | 8-3 | Won 8 | W, 77-65 (11/24/98) |
| St. Norbert College | 25-47 | Won 2 | W, 74-72 (1/21/20) |
| St. Olaf College | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 75-52 (12/29/04) |
| St. Thomas, University of | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 51-83 (12/30/17) |
| St. Xavier College | 4-1 | Lost 1 | L, 51-62 (2/18/82) |
| Teikyo Marycrest College | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 66-63 (11/25/94) |
| Trinity Christian College | 2-5 | Lost 5 | L, 53-70 (2/3/97) |
| Trinity International University | 13-4 | Won 1 | W, 73-48 (1/5/06) |
| Trinity University (TX) | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 52-70 (12/31/04) |
| Triton College | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 61-51 (12/4/79) |
| Virginia Wesleyan University | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 80-56 (12/17/06) |
| Washington University | 1-6 | Lost 3 | L, 38-78 (11/15/14) |
| Washington & Lee University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 45-86 (12/20/21) |
| Webster University | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 62-90 (11/13/21) |
| Wheaton College | 5-8 | Lost 3 | L, 50-73 (11/15/19) |
| Willamette University | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 38-43 (12/20/14) |
| William Patterson College | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 62-63 (12/30/96) |
| William Penn University | 1-1 | Won 1 | W, 89-75 (11/25/95) |
| Williams College | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 70-73 (ot) (12/30/16) |
| Wisconsin Lutheran College | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 62-70 (11/16/19) |
| Wisconsin-Eau Claire, University of | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 53-58 (11/20/04) |
| Wisconsin-La Crosse, University of | 1-1 | Lost 1 | L, 47-60 (11/30/19) |
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh, University of | 1-4 | Lost 3 | L, 58-64 (11/16/13) |
| Wisconsin-Parkside, University of | 0-4 | Lost 4 | L, 77-89 (12/10/88) |
| Wisconsin-Platteville, University of | 2-3 | Lost 2 | L, 59-68 (12/30/22) |
| Wisconsin-River Falls, University of | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 89-80 (12/1/19) |
| Wisconsin-Stevens Point, University of | 0-2 | Lost 2 | L, 61-64 (11/15/13) |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater, University of | 1-4 | Lost 2 | L, 49-99 (1/30/22) |
| Wooster College | 2-0 | Won 2 | W, 76-69 (11/28/97) |
| Worcester Polytechnic Institute | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 66-41 (12/28/99) |
| Worcester State University | 1-0 | Won 1 | W, 77-68 (12/19/22) |
| Wright J.C. | 0-1 | Lost 1 | L, 53-58 (1/4/79) |