| HEAD COACH | YEAR(S) | MEN | WOMEN | TOTAL |
| Vadim Tashlitsky | 2008-23 (15 years) | 56-37 (.602), 2 titles | 57-36-1 (.612), 2 titles | 113-73-1 (.607), 4 titles |
| Skip Cook | 1985-93 (8 years) | 51-22 (.699), 2 titles | 53-18 (.746), 4 titles | 104-40 (.722), 6 titles |
| John Leonard (Hall of Fame) | 1979-84 (5 years) | 23-32 (.418) | 47-9 (.839), 1 title | 70-41 (.630), 1 title |
| Tom Burton (Hall of Fame) | 1993-99 (6 years) | 25-17 (.595), 3 titles | 38-7 (.844), 4 titles | 63-24 (.724), 7 titles |
| Alec Webster | 1999-06 (7 years) | 23-20 (.535), 1 title | 28-15 (.651) | 51-35 (.593), 1 title |
| Ramsey Van Horn | 1976-79 (3 years) | 16-15 (.516), 1 title | 18-11 (.621) | 34-26 (.567), 1 title |
| Karl Sutter | 1969-74 (5 years) * | 11-12 (.478) | 9-2 (.818) | 20-14 (.588) |
| Maureen Sheehan | 1984-85 (1 year) | 6-3 (.667) | 8-2 (.800) | 14-5 (.737) |
| Dan Shelley | 2006-08 (2 years) | 4-12 (.250) | 3-13 (.188) | 7-25 (.219) |
| Rich Mull | 1974-76 (2 years) * | 3-8 (.273) | 3-8 (.273) |
* Records are incomplete