| YEAR | PLAYER, CLASS, POSITION | AWARD |
| 2023 | Angelle Bills, JR, C Kristen Calhoun, SR, P Elena Chrisman, SR, OF Teagan Delarwelle, JR, 1B Hannah Smith, SO, P |
CSC Academic All-District® CSC Academic All-District® CSC Academic All-District® CSC Academic All-District® CSC Academic All-District® |
| 2022 | Angelle Bills, SO, C/UTIL Brooke Challe, FR, P Elena Chrisman, JR, OF Kelly Collins, FR, IF Teagan Delarwelle, C/IF Josie Klein, SR, OF Carlie Mertz, SR, P/UTIL Hannah Smith, FR, P |
Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete Easton/NFCA All-American Scholar-Athlete |
| 2021 | Shaye Gauthier, SR, 2B/P Joe Kinsella, Laura Fillipp, Anthony Fagan |
Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award Midwest Conference North Division Coaching Staff of the Year |
| 2020 | Shaye Gauthier, JR, IF/P | CoSIDA First Team Academic All-District® |
| 2019 | Joe Kinsella Shaye Gauthier, SO, IF/P Shaye Gauthier, SO, IF/P Kyra Lenzi, SR, P Maria Zepeda, SR, OF |
Midwest Conference Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2018 | Kat Beall, SR, SS/2B Kat Beall, SR, SS/2B |
Midwest Conference Ruth Peterson Award Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award |
| 2017 | Kat Beall, JR, SS | Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award |
| 2016 | Kat Beall, SO, SS Jessi Werner, SR, P Alex Hemmer, SR, C Maria Zepeda, FR, OF |
Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2015 | Jenny McTague, SO, P Kayla Borgra, SR, OF Alex Hemmer, JR, C Jessi Werner, JR, P |
NCAA Regional Tournament Most Outstanding Player NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2014 | Joe Kinsella Sam Ritsema, SR, SS Jenny McTague, FR, P |
MWC South Division Coach of the Year NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2013 | Sam Ritsema, JR, SS | NFCA Division III Scholar-Athlete |
| 2010 | Joe Kinsella | MWC South Division Coach of the Year |
| 2009 | Joe Kinsella | MWC South Division Coach of the Year |
| 2006 | Tina Johnson Melissa Wegner, SR Melissa Wegner, SR Melissa Wegner, SR |
MWC South Division Coach of the Year First Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) Third Team Academic All-American College Division (CoSIDA) Nicholas J. Wasylik Award |
| 2005 | Lisa Jeziorny, SO, C Melissa Wegner, JR, SS Alissa Mildebrath, SR, 2B Erin Watts, SO, OF |
NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2004 | Jenny Riddle, FR, UTIL Leigh Anne Furgerson, SR, P |
NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team Second Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) |
| 2003 | Leigh Anne Furgerson, JR, P Tina Koludrovic, SO, SS Shannon Clerkin, SO, 1B Megan Gibson, SR, 2B |
NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team |
| 2002 | Diane Kanney, Chris Pier, Jill Popovich Diane Kanney, Chris Pier, Jill Popovich Nancy Findeisen, SO, P Leigh Anne Furgerson, SO, P Tina Koludrovic, FR, SS Robyn Slater, JR, 3B Nancy Findeisen, SO, P Jenn Reifenberg, SR, C Alissa Mildebrath, FR, 2B Robyn Slater, JR, 3B Kristin Brand, SR, OF Diane Kanney |
National Coaching Staff of the Year (NFCA) Great Lakes Regional Coaching Staff of the Year (NFCA) NCAA National All-Tournament Team NCAA National All-Tournament Team NCAA National All-Tournament Team NCAA National All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team NCAA Regional All-Tournament Team MWC South Division Coach of the Year |
| 2001 | Diane Kanney | MWC South Division Coach of the Year |
| 2000 | Karyn Leniek, SR | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1999 | Karyn Leniek, JR | GTE/CoSIDA College Division Academic All-District V Team |
| 1998 | Diane Kanney | MWC South Division Coach of the Year |
| 1993 | Anne Bennett, SR Anne Woll, FR |
Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1991 | Nicole Angeli, SR | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1990 | Katherine Palmer, SR | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1989 | Nicoel Angeli, SO | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1988 | Katherine Palmer, SO | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1987 | Kelly Harmon, SO | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1986 | Jenny Youngquist, SR, 2B | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1984 | Deborah Dalzell, JR | Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1983 | Cindy Hahn, FR, 3B/SS | Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1981 | Carolyn Schuetz, FR, P | Freshman Letterman's Award |