| YEAR | CAPTAIN(S) |
| 2023 | Elena Chrisman, Kelly Collins |
| 2022 | Hailey Boylan, Josie Klein |
| 2021 | Shaye Gauthier, Erin Karasewski |
| 2019 | Maria Zepeda, Sydney Wyatt |
| 2018 | Kat Beall, Sydney Gardner |
| 2017 | Jenny McTague, Sydney Gardner |
| 2016 | Jessi Werner, Sally Snarski |
| 2015 | Kayla Borgra, Whitney Leiderman |
| 2014 | Sam Ritsema, Kayla Borgra |
| 2013 | Nikki Miller, Aubrey Pendegraft |
| 2012 | Cami Daun, Danielle Gore |
| 2011 | Leslie Harshey, Danielle Gore |
| 2010 | Jill Pfund, Tracy Rainey |
| 2009 | Hannah Michal, Jill Pfund |
| 2008 | Christy Condon, Kendra Grant |
| 2007 | Lisa Jeziorny, Erin Watts |
| 2006 | Melissa Wegner, Ashley Closson |
| 2005 | Alissa Mildebrath, Melissa Wegner |
| 2004 | Leigh Anne Furgerson, Alissa Mildebrath |
| 2003 | Robyn Slater, Leigh Anne Furgerson |
| 2002 | Chris Laurine, Jenn Reifenberg |
| 2001 | Kim Magee, Chris Laurine |
| 2000 | Jessie Griffin, Kim Magee |
| 1999 | Jessie Griffin, Karen Siska |
| 1998 | Anna Youngerman |
| 1997 | Anna Youngerman, Tanya Lazaro |
| 1996 | Kristine Reese, Tanya Lazaro |
| 1995 | Kiersten Kolbu |
| 1994 | Stacey Montano, Sarah Beckstrom |
| 1993 | Marcy Mustafa, Kim Neumann |
| 1992 | Kathy Hafenscher, Jen Courts |
| 1991 | Nicole Angeli, Shelly Keller |
| 1990 | Katy Palmer, Tammy Hanke |
| 1989 | Eve Alexander, Renee Weitendorf |
| 1988 | Eve Alexander, Renee Weitendorf |
| 1987 | Lori Edenhofer, Judy Wiesbrook |
| 1986 | Cindy Hahn, Jenny Youngquist |
| 1985 | Donna Lawlor, Debbie Boe, Laurie Doss |
| 1984 | Donna Lawlor, Debbie Boe |
| 1983 | Donna Lawlor |
| 1982 | Laurie Doss, Rita Gordon |
| 1981 | Chris Carlo, Claudia Kuzyk |
| 1980 | Julie Campbell, Caryl Weisbecker |
| 1979 | Claudia Kuzyk, Julie Campbell, Terre Rappa |