| YEAR | STUDENT-ATHLETE, CLASS |
| 2023 | Angelle Bills, JR Kristen Calhoun, SR Kyla Chevalier, FR Elena Chrisman, SR Kayla Collins, FR Teagan Delarwelle, JR Cadence Dempsey, FR Alexa Paulsberg, FR Cheyenne Pellettiere, SO Kaylee Purgatorio, SO Hannah Smith, SO Brooke Swiecki, FR Morgan Traxinger, FR |
| 2022 | Angelle Bills, SO Brooke Challe, FR Elena Chrisman, JR Kelly Collins, FR Teagan Delarwelle, SO Josie Klein, SR Carlie Mertz, SR Hannah Smith, FR |
| 2021 | Kasey Beck, FR Angelle Bills, FR Kristen Calhoun, SO Anny Caskey, FR Brie Gauthier, SO Shaye Gauthier, SR Hannah Kalnicky, SR Erin Karasewski, SR Josie Klein, JR Melissa Manzo, SO Carlie Mertz, JR Abby Ponder, SR Nicole Schussler, SR Maddie Webb, SR |
| 2020 | Missy Dieckman-Meyer, SR Brie Gauthier, FR Shaye Gauthier, JR Hannah Kalnicky, JR Erin Karasewski, JR Josie Klein, SO Melissa Manzo, FR Abby Ponder, JR Nicole Schussler, JR Haylee Sherlund, SR Maddie Webb, JR Sydney Wyatt, SR |
| 2019 | Missy Dieckman-Meyer, JR Shaye Gauthier, SO Alyssa Grimm, SR Hannah Kalnicky, SO Erin Karasewski, SO Josie Klein, FR Nicole Schussler, SO Haylee Sherlund, JR |
| 2018 | Kat Beall, SR Megan Dahlinger, SR Missy Dieckman-Meyer, SO Sydney Gardner, SR Shaye Gauthier, FR Quinn Jagodzinski, SO McKenzie Jordan, SO Hannah Kalnicky, FR Erin Karasewski, FR Abby King, JR Nicole Schussler, FR Haylee Sherlund, SO Maddie Webb, FR Sydney Wyatt, SO |
| 2017 | Kat Beall, JR Megan Dahlinger, JR Quinn Jagodzinski, FR McKenzie Jordan, FR Abby King, SO Jenny McTague, SR Haylee Sherlund, FR Sydney Wyatt, FR |
| 2016 | Tara Airola, JR Kat Beall, SO Jenny Carpenter, SO Alex Hemmer, SR Abby King, FR Jenny McTague, JR Alex Milat, SO Vasi Panos, SR Jillian Rashid, SO |
| 2015 | Tara Airola, SO Kaleigh Ambrose, JR Kat Beall, FR Maddie Dieleman, JR Audrey Djukic, SR Alex Hemmer, JR McKenzie Mac, FR Jenny McTague, SO Vasi Panos, JR |
| 2014 | Sam Ritsema, SR Maddie Dieleman, SO Alex Hemmer, SO Tara Airola, FR Jenny McTague, FR |
| 2013 | Sam Ritsema, JR Maddie Dieleman, FR |
| 2012 | Danielle Gore, SR Leslie Harshey, SR Kelly Chesnut, JR Megan Harkins, JR Nikki Miller, JR Molly Thomsen, JR Nora Logue, SO Sam Ritsema, SO |
| 2011 | Danielle Gore, JR Leslie Harshey, JR Kelly Chesnut, SO Megan Harkins, SO Nikki Miller, SO Molly Thomsen, SO |
| 2010 | Jill Pfund, SR Danielle Gore, SO |
| 2009 | Jill Pfund, JR Charice Wilczynski, JR Kaylee Gendrich, SO |
| 2008 | Christy Condon, SR Rachael Pasdo, SR Jill Pfund, SO |
| 2007 | Kim Silvers, SR Lisa Jeziorny, SR Erin Watts, SR Rachael Pasdo, JR Alex Charron, SO |
| 2006 | Ashley Closson, SR Melissa Wegner, SR Kim Silvers, JR Lisa Jeziorny, JR Erin Watts, JR Christy Condon, SO Rachael Pasdo, SO |
| 2005 | Ashley Closson, JR Melissa Wegner, JR Kim Silvers, SO |
| 2004 | Ashley Closson, SO Leigh Anne Furgerson, SR Melissa Wegner, SO |
| 2003 | Leigh Anne Furgerson, JR Tina Koludrovic, SO Shannon Clerkin, SO Robyn Slater, SR |
| 2002 | Leigh Anne Furgerson, SO Robyn Slater, JR |
| 2001 | Megan Gibson, SO Chrissy Roiniotis, SO Robyn Slater, SO |
| 2000 | Karyn Leniek, SR Heather McCarthy, SO |
| 1999 | Karyn Leniek, JR Chrissy Dickerson, SO |
| 1998 | Anna Youngerman, SR Michelle Vandigo, SR |
| 1997 | Anna Youngerman, JR Kim Leniek, SR Tanya Lazaro, SR |
| 1996 | Anne Woll, SR Tanya Lazaro, JR Tracy Frederick, JR Michelle Vandigo, SO |
| 1995 | Amy Betchelder, SO Kim Leniek, SO Yvette Loizon, SO Anne Woll, JR |
| 1994 | Sarah Beckstrom, SR Stacey Montano, SR |
| 1991 | Nicole Angeli, SR |