| OPPONENT | OVERALL RECORD | LAST MEETING | RESULT |
| Adrian College | 1-0 | 3/27/10 | W, 6-3 |
| Albion College * | 2-2 | 2/15/14 | W, 5-4 |
| Alma College | 1-1 | 3/27/10 | W, 6-3 |
| Amherst College | 0-1 | 3/15/17 | L, 0-9 |
| Asbury University | 0-1 | 3/27/23 | L, 2-7 |
| Augustana College * | 4-1 | 1/28/17 | W, 5-4 |
| Aurora University | 7-1 | 4/13/10 | W, 8-1 |
| Baldwin-Wallace College | 0-2 | 3/12/14 | L, 3-6 |
| Beloit College * | 18-7 | 4/10/10 | W, 9-0 |
| Berry College | 0-3 | 3/13/20 | L, 2-7 |
| Brigham Young University | 0-2 | 2000 | L, 0-5 |
| California Institute of Technology | 1-0 | 3/11/08 | W, 5-2 |
| Calvin College | 1-3 | 2/27/20 | W, 7-2 |
| Cardinal Stritch University | 0-1 | 1/31/15 | L, 0-9 |
| Carroll University * | 21-7 | 2/8/20 | W, 7-2 |
| Carthage College * | 13-24 | 3/24/23 | L, 1-8 |
| Case Western Reserve University | 0-1 | 4/7/23 | L, 1-8 |
| Catholic University | 1-0 | 3/14/19 | W, 8-1 |
| Central Michigan University | 1-0 | 1966 | W, 6-3 |
| Chaminade University | 1-0 | 2000 | W, 2-4 |
| Chapman College | 0-1 | 3/16/18 | L, 2-7 |
| Chicago State University * | 8-0 | 1986 | W, 8-1 |
| Chicago University | 0-2 | 1951 | L, 2-7 |
| Chicago, University of * | 11-16 | 2/16/13 | L, 0-9 |
| Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Colleges | 0-1 | 3/14/08 | L, 0-9 |
| Coe College | 1-3 | 2000 | L, 1-6 |
| Colby-Sawyer College | 1-0 | 3/10/10 | W, 8-1 |
| College of Dupage | 1-0 | 1998 | W, 6-1 |
| College of Lake County * | 4-2 | 1995 | L, 3-6 |
| Concord College (WV) | 1-0 | 1995 | W, 9-1 |
| Concordia University Chicago * | 21-2 | 3/4/17 | W, 9-0 |
| Concordia University Wisconsin | 7-2 | 2/8/20 | W, 5-4 |
| Connecticut, University of | 0-1 | 3/7/10 | L, 0-7 |
| Cornell College | 9-5 | 4/28/23 | W, 5-0 |
| Defiance College | 1-0 | 2007 | W, 9-0 |
| Denison University | 0-1 | 3/12/12 | L, 1-8 |
| Depaul University * | 4-9 | 1991 | L, 0-9 |
| DePauw University * | 0-3 | 1964 | L, 4-5 |
| Dickinson College | 1-0 | 3/14/23 | W, 6-3 |
| Dominican University | 6-0 | 4/17/19 | W, 8-1 |
| Eastern Nazarene College | 1-0 | 2004 | W, 7-0 |
| Edgewood College | 4-0 | 2/10/18 | W, 8-1 |
| Elmhurst University * | 12-6 | 2/25/22 | W, 5-4 |
| Fairfield University | 0-1 | 2003 | L, 2-5 |
| Franklin & Marshall College | 0-1 | 1996 | L, 2-7 |
| Gettysburg College | 3-1 | 3/9/22 | W, 5-4 |
| Gordon College | 1-0 | 3/14/19 | W, 6-3 |
| Great Lakes Naval Tennis Club * | 5-1 | 1972 | W, 5-4 |
| Green Mountain College | 1-0 | 2004 | L, 2-5 |
| Greenville University | 1-0 | 3/13/23 | W, 5-4 |
| Grinnell College | 5-33 | 4/28/23 | L, 0-5 |
| Haverford College | 1-0 | 1998 | W, 6-1 |
| Hawaii, University of | 0-2 | 2001 | L, 0-7 |
| Heidelberg College | 3-0 | 3/12/14 | W, 7-2 |
| Hilton Head (SC) | 0-1 | 1995 | L, 4-6 |
| Hood College | 1-0 | 2007 | W, 9-0 |
| Hope College * | 1-0 | 1972 | W, 7-1 |
| Hope International University | 0-1 | 3/15/18 | L, 0-9 |
| Illinois Benedictine University | 5-2 | 1989 | W, 7-2 |
| Illinois-Chicago, University of * | 4-6 | 1990 | L, 4-5 |
| Illinois College | 27-0 | 4/15/23 | W, 9-0 |
| Illinois Institute of Technology * | 4-2 | 2/18/23 | W, 8-1 |
| Illinois (Navy Pier) * | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Illinois Wesleyan University * | 7-2 | 2/24/18 | W, 6-0 |
| Judson University | 1-2 | 3/19/22 | L, 2-7 |
| Juniata College | 1-0 | 3/9/16 | W, 8-1 |
| Kalamazoo College * | 0-5 | 2/6/16 | L, 0-9 |
| Knox College | 21-11 | 3/30/19 | W, 8-1 |
| Lakeland College | 5-0 | 2/13/10 | W, 6-1 |
| La Sierra University | 0-1 | 3/9/08 | L, 4-5 |
| La Verne, University of | 1-0 | 3/12/08 | W, 5-4 |
| Lawrence University * | 20-14 | 4/22/23 | W, 9-0 |
| LeTourneau University | 0-1 | 3/11/20 | L, 2-7 |
| Lewis University | 1-0 | 1975 | W, 8-1 |
| Luther College | 0-1 | 2007 | L, 0-9 |
| Lynchburg, University of | 0-1 | 3/13/20 | L, 4-5 |
| Macalester College | 0-2 | 2002 | L, 1-6 |
| Manchester College | 1-0 | 3/20/10 | W, 9-0 |
| Manhattanville College | 1-0 | 2007 | W, 9-0 |
| Marian College | 3-0 | 2/17/08 | W, 8-1 |
| Marquette University * | 1-6 | 1981 | L, 1-8 |
| Mary Hardin-Baylor, University of | 1-0 | 3/10/11 | W, 5-4 |
| McDaniel College | 1-0 | 3/12/17 | W, 9-0 |
| Messiah College | 1-0 | 1997 | W, 7-2 |
| Millikin University * | 3-3 | 3/9/20 | W, 6-3 |
| Millsaps College | 1-1 | 3/6/11 | W, 6-3 |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | 18-1 | 9/18/23 | L, 4-5 |
| Monmouth College | 13-9 | 4/15/23 | W, 9-0 |
| Montana State University-Billings | 0-1 | 2003 | L, 0-9 |
| Morningside University | 0-1 | 3/11/22 | L, 1-6 |
| Mount Union College | 0-1 | 2004 | L, 3-4 |
| Nazareth College | 2-0 | 3/11/19 | W, 9-0 |
| North Central College * | 13-3 | 2/27/21 | L, 1-8 |
| Northeastern Illinois University | 5-3 | 1992 | L, 0-9 |
| Northern Illinois University * | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| North Park * | 7-3 | 1995 | W, 9-0 |
| Northwestern JV | 4-1 | 1982 | W, 7-2 |
| Northwestern University | 0-3 | 1977 | L, 2-5 |
| Northwestern, University of | 1-0 | 2/20/16 | W, 7-2 |
| NYU | 0-1 | 2001 | L, 0-7 |
| Oakton Community College | 1-0 | 2000 | W, 7-0 |
| Oberlin College | 0-1 | 2/8/14 | L, 0-9 |
| Oglethorpe University | 0-2 | 3/7/16 | L, 3-6 |
| Ohio Northern University | 0-1 | 3/7/22 | L, 1-8 |
| Ohio Wesleyan University | 0-1 | 1964 | L, 1-8 |
| Penn State Behrend | 1-0 | 2004 | W, 5-2 |
| Penn State Berks | 1-0 | 3/10/15 | W, 9-0 |
| Pfeiffer University | 0-1 | 3/8/22 | L, 4-5 |
| Principia College | 3-1 | 3/25/23 | W, 8-1 |
| Quinnipiac College | 0-1 | 1999 | L, 3-4 |
| Radford University | 0-1 | 1999 | L, 0-7 |
| Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | 0-1 | 2002 | L, 0-7 |
| Ripon College * | 13-15 | 4/22/23 | W, 9-0 |
| Rockford College * | 9-0 | 2/27/10 | W, 9-0 |
| Roger Williams University | 1-0 | 3/12/15 | W, 5-4 |
| Roosevelt University | 0-1 | 2/15/20 | L, 3-6 |
| Rosary College * | N/A | 1993 | N/A |
| Schreiner University | 1-0 | 3/11/11 | W, 8-1 |
| Scranton, University of | 1-0 | 3/15/12 | W, 6-2 |
| Shenandoah University | 0-1 | 3/16/23 | L, 3-6 |
| Siena College | 1-0 | 1998 | W, 7-0 |
| Southwestern University | 1-0 | 3/11/11 | W, 7-2 |
| Springfield College | 0-1 | 2006 | L, 3-4 |
| St. Francis, University of | 0-3 | 2/20/22 | L, 3-6 |
| St. Joseph's College (IN) | 0-1 | 2004 | L, 0-7 |
| St. Mary's University (MN) | 1-0 | 1985 | W, 7-2 |
| St. Norbert College | 22-10 | 5/1/21 | W, 9-0 |
| St. Scholastica, College of | 0-1 | 3/12/17 | L, 4-5 |
| Texas-Dallas, University of | 0-1 | 3/8/11 | L, 4-5 |
| Texas-Tyler, University of | 0-1 | 3/5/11 | L, 1-8 |
| Tiffin University | 1-0 | 2007 | W, 6-3 |
| Transylvania University | 0-1 | 2006 | L, 2-5 |
| Trinity International University * | 5-0 | 2000 | W, 6-1 |
| Ursinus College | 1-2 | 3/10/16 | L, 4-5 |
| Valparaiso University * | 2-1 | 2002 | L, 0-7 |
| Vassar College | 0-1 | 2001 | L, 0-7 |
| Wabash College * | 1-8 | 3/7/22 | W, 8-1 |
| Wartburg College | 1-0 | 2/10/23 | W, 8-1 |
| Washington College | 0-1 | 3/10/19 | L, 0-9 |
| Washington University | 0-1 | 1998 | L, 1-6 |
| Wayne State University | 2-0 | 1972 | W, 8-1 |
| Webster University | 1-0 | 3/22/14 | W, 7-2 |
| Western Illinois University * | 1-0 | 1972 | W, 8-1 |
| Wheaton College * | 7-16 | 2/4/23 | L, 3-6 |
| Wisconsin, University of * | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| Wisconsin-Eau Claire, University of | 0-4 | 4/1/23 | L, 4-5 |
| Wisconsin-LaCrosse, University of | 2-4 | 3/15/17 | L, 2-7 |
| Wisconsin-Milwaukee, University of | 1-2 | 1985 | L, 0-9 |
| Wisconsin-Oshkosh, University of | 4-3 | 2/13/16 | W, 7-2 |
| Wisconsin-Parkside, University of | 0-1 | 1983 | L, 4-5 |
| Wisconsin-Stout, University of | 0-3 | 1985 | L, 1-8 |
| Wisconsin-Whitewater, University of | 0-9 | 2/7/15 | L, 1-8 |
| Wisconsin Lutheran College | 2-0 | 2/3/18 | W, 9-0 |
| Wittenberg University | 1-0 | 3/8/16 | W, 9-0 |
| Wooster, College of | 1-3 | 3/11/15 | L, 1-8 |
| *Incomplete Overall Record | |||