| YEAR | PLAYER/COACH | AWARD |
| 2021 | Anthony DerManulian, SR, OL Anthony DerManulian, SR, OL Jim Catanzaro Vincent Wallace, JR, QB Jamari Tansmore, SR, DL |
CoSIDA Second Team Academic All-America® CoSIDA Academic All-District® Midwest Conference Coach of the Year Midwest Conference Elite 20 Award National Football Foundation William V. Campbell Trophy® Semifinalist |
| 2020-21 | A.J. Jackson, SO, PR A.J. Jackson, SO, KR John Colasacco, SR, OL |
College Football American 2020 Yearbook NCAA Division III Starting Lineup D3football.com Preseason First Team All-American National Football Foundation William V. Campbell Trophy® Semifinalist |
| 2019 | Ted Crane, SR Bill Degnan, SR Johnny Laponte, SR Noah Recker, SR |
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2018 | Cade Britain, SR Jagan Cleary, SR Chase Creviston, SR Nick Edlund, SR Ben Taylor, SR Zach Wade, SR |
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2017 | Isaac Barthelmess, SR Michael Cole, SR Kevin Curameng, SR Miko Delacruz, SR Tim Finucane, SR Hector Mendoza, SR Sam Plutchak, SR Ryan Shalosky, SR Tom Steen, SR |
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2016 | Sam Mulford, SR Brendan Power, SR |
National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2015 | George Vidas, SR | National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2013 | Michael Garetto-Balmer, SR Ed Dobernig, SR Michael Garetto-Balmer, SR Jake Rotkvich, SR |
Capital One Academic All-District® National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society |
| 2012 | Jim Catanzaro Aidan Price, SR, DB Ben Larsen, SO, K |
Midwest Conference Coach of the Year National Football Foundation Hampshire Honor Society Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2011 | Luke Butts, SR, DB | Nick Wasylik Senior Athletic Award |
| 2009 | Jaron Eanes, SR, DL | Nicholas J. Wasylik Award |
| 2007 | Rick Storkan, FR, RB | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2006 | Rick Storkan, FR, RB | Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2004 | David Bleitner, SR, DL David Bleitner, SR, DL |
First Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) Second Team Academic All-American (ESPN The Magazine) |
| 2003 | David Bleitner, JR, DL Brian Bonnell, SR, DB Tony Bertuca, SR, OL |
First Team Academic All-District V College Division (CoSIDA) Senior Scholar/Athlete Award Nicholas J. Wasylik Award |
| 2002 | Brian Bonnell, JR, DB Chad Eisele |
Junior Scholar/Athlete Award Midwest Conference Coach of the Year |
| 2001 | Brian Bonnell, SO, DB | Sophomore Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 2000 | Brian Bonnell, FR, DB | Freshman Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1998 | Simon Kotlyar, SR, RB | Burger King Scholar Athlete ($10,000 scholarship) |
| 1989 | Craig Salters, SO, OL | Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1988 | Jeffrey Griffith, JR | Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1987 | Pat Holly, JR, OL | Junior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1986 | John Jahn, SR, OT | Alternate for the '87 Hula Bowl All-Star Game (First NCAA Division III player to be invited) |
| 1984 | Pat Horne, JR, LB | Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1983 | Pat Horne, SO, LB Joe Whalen, FR, QB |
Sophomore Letterman's Award Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1980 | Ed Pluchar, SR, T | Senior Scholar/Athlete Award |
| 1979 | Ed Pluchar, JR, T Robert Winikates, SO, G |
Junior Letterman's Award Sophomore Letterman's Award |
| 1976 | Tony Wall, SO, DE Andy Livingston, JR, DL Jon Pratt, JR, G |
Illinois-Sports Information Director All-State College Division Honorable Mention All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1975 | Rodney Mruk, SR Ross Bricker, JR Jon Pratt, SO, G |
Senior Letterman's Award Junior Letterman's Award Sophomore Letterman's Award |
| 1974 | Greg Evans, SR, E Ken Kaduk, SR, DT Rodney Mruk, JR |
Honorable Mention All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) Senior Letterman's Award Junior Letterman's Award |
| 1973 | Ken Kaduk, JR, DT Ken Kaduk, JR, DT Michael Dwyer, SO William Murray, FR |
First Team All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) Junior Letterman's Award Sophomore Letterman's Award Freshman Letterman's Award |
| 1972 | Joe Aukstolis, SR, G | Honorable Mention All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) |
| 1964 | Grant Abrahamson, G | Honorable Mention All-District (N.A. I.A. 20) |
| 1962 | Bob Hoberg | All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) |
| 1960 | Tom Lewis, SR, E Bill Hitchcock, SR, OG Tom Lewis, SR, E |
All-State Collegiate Team (Peoria Journal Star) All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) All-District (N.A.I.A. 20) |
| 1957 | Mike Dau, SR, G Jack Kammes, LT John Hartford, SO, FB Dave Parker, JR, E Larry McClain, FR, QB Wally Lemm Wally Lemm |
First Team Collegiate All-State (Peoria Journal Star) Second Team Collegiate All-State Fourth Team Collegiate All-State Fourth Team Collegiate All-State Honorable Mention Collegiate All-State Small College Coach of the Year District Coach of the Year (N.A.I.A. 20) |
| 1938 | John Biolo, G | All-Illinois Team |