| YEAR | PLAYER, CLASS, POSITION |
| 2022 | Alex Bendler, SR, DL |
| 2021 | A.J. Jackson, JR, WR |
| 2019 | Jordan McInerney, SR, DE |
| 2018 | Ethan Sheirer, SR, OL |
| 2017 | Joey Valdivia, SR, RB |
| 2016 | Joey Valdivia, JR, RB |
| 2015 | Charlie Quinn, JR, RB |
| 2014 | John Preston, SR, LB |
| 2013 | Jake Rotkvich, SR, DL |
| 2012 | Austin Sobey, SR, WR |
| 2011 | Kevin Davis, SR, WR |
| 2010 | Luke Butts, JR, DB |
| 2009 | Dan Carter, SR, WR |
| 2008 | Dan Carter, JR, WR |
| 2007 | Jeff Ziemnik, SR, QB |
| 2006 | Jeff Ziemnik, JR, QB |
| 2005 | Jeff Huebner, SR, WR |
| 2004 | Nick Hildreth, SR, WR |
| 2003 | Pat Gillihan, SR, DB |
| 2002 | Casey Urlacher, SR, LB |
| 2001 | Casey Urlacher, JR, LB |
| 2000 | Casey Urlacher, SO, LB |
| 1999 | Bernie Perconti, SR, LB |
| 1998 | David Fee, SR, RB/K/P |
| 1997 | Phil Persoon, SR, LB |
| 1996 | Corey Honore, JR, RB |
| 1995 | John Klasen, SR, RB |
| 1994 | John Klasen, JR, RB |
| 1993 | John Klasen, SO, RB |
| 1992 | Butch Bendery, JR, LB/TE |
| 1991 | Bill Brown, JR, DB |
| 1990 | Gary Francis, SR, LB |
| 1989 | Steve Pape, SR, DL |
| 1988 | Ed Bohan, SR, DB |
| 1987 | Ed Bohan, JR, DB |
| 1986 | Jeff Jatis, Sr, MLB |
| 1985 | Colin Lundgren, SR, WR |
| 1984 | Scott Knous, SR, FB |
| 1983 | Offense: Chris Jensen, SR, WR Defense: Bob Shaw, SR, DT |
| 1982 | Offense: Chris Jensen, JR, WR Defense: Bob Shaw, JR, DT |
| 1981 | Ray Hagen, SR, C |
| 1980 | Jon Wynn, SR, DT |
| 1979 | John Joyce, SR, HB |
| 1978 | Offense: Frank Melch, SO, QB Defense: Bill Bremer, SR, LB |
| 1977 | Offense: Peter Magrini, FR, FB Defense: Ken Addison, Sr, SS |
| 1976 | Ken Addison & John Coghlan |
| 1975 | Offense: George Latto & Stan Lukaszewski Defense: Dave Bowerman |
| 1974 | Offense: Terry Stenger Defense: L.D. Ross |
| 1973 | Offense: Terry Stenger Defense: Fritz Regner |
| 1972 | Offense: B. Kelleher Defense: Fritz Regner |
| 1971 | Did not field a team (insufficient numbers). |
| 1970 | T. Kingman & T. Porter |
| 1969 | T. Carr, D. Fitzpatrick, T. Jaax & T. Woodard |
| 1968 | T. Jaax |
| 1967 | Tom Carr & John Wyatt |
| 1966 | James Cartier |
| 1965 | Rick Kolowski |
| 1964 | Grant Abrahamson, JR |
| 1963 | Jim Harris |
| 1962 | Ed Young |
| 1961 | Butch Barr |
| 1960 | Bill Hitchcock |
| 1959 | E. Young |
| 1958 | Harley Wahl, SR, DHB/HB |
| 1957 | Mike Dau, SR |
| 1956 | Ed Chvatal |
| 1955 | Jim Hisler & Ed Williams |
| 1954 | Stuart Currie |
| 1953 | Charles Sterling |
| 1952 | Leo Ferrari |
| 1951 | Jay Blessing, SR |
| 1950 | Jack Dougherty, SR |
| 1949 | N/A |
| 1948 | N/A |
| 1947 | George Gutnik |
| 1946 | Jerome "Mike" Powers |
| 1945 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1944 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1943 | Did not field a team (WWII). |
| 1942 | George Petty, SR |
| 1941 | Angelo Palango, SR, QB, LH |
| 1940 | Joe Ogrin, SR, G |
| 1939 | Robert "Roly" Caruthers |
| 1938 | Robert "Roly" Caruthers |
| 1937 | J. Eiserman |
| 1936 | N/A |
| 1935 | N/A |
| 1934 | N/A |
| 1933 | N/A |
| 1932 | A. Goodman |
| 1931 | N/A |
| 1930 | Faust "Frosty" Ferzacca, SR, QB/Def. |
| 1929 | Faust "Frosty" Ferzacca, JR |
| 1928 | R. Englund |
| 1927 | Peter Mayer |
| 1926 | H. Flancher |