| YEAR | PLAYER, CLASS, POSITION |
| 2022 | Alan Hanson, SR, TE |
| 2021 | Dante Esposito, JR, DB |
| 2019 | Connor Cahill, SO, OL |
| 2018 | Jordan McInerney, JR, LB |
| 2017 | Jenri Salonga, SR, DB |
| 2016 | Chris Edomwande, SO, WR |
| 2015 | Sean Chapman, SR, LB |
| 2014 | Jared Russ, JR, WR |
| 2013 | George Vidas, SO, WR |
| 2012 | Jake Julius, JR, LB |
| 2011 | Austin Sobey, JR, WR |
| 2010 | Kevin Davis, JR, WR |
| 2009 | Casey Flynn, SO, DL |
| 2008 | Tanner Compton, SO, LB |
| 2007 | Tim Paulsen, SR, DL |
| 2006 | Kevin Carter, SR, LB/RB |
| 2005 | Andre Washington, SR, RB |
| 2004 | Anthony Gebhart, SO, RB |
| 2003 | David Bleitner, JR, DL |
| 2002 | Mike Fitzgerald, SR, WR |
| 2001 | Nick Rossi, SO, WR |
| 2000 | Chad Carroll, SR, DT |
| 1999 | Russ Hennings, SR, OL |
| 1998 | Dustin Cassady, JR, DL |
| 1997 | Simon Kotlyar, JR, FB |
| 1996 | Mike Swafford, SR, OL |
| 1995 | Jon O'Hern, FR, OL |
| 1994 | Brennan Young, SO, QB |
| 1993 | Sam Bodine, SR, DE |
| 1992 | Erik Rasmussen, JR, TE |
| 1991 | Mike May, SR, DB |
| 1990 | Eric Kalata, JR, DL |
| 1989 | Jay Ferrari, JR, OB |
| 1988 | Jeff Griffith, SO, TE |
| 1987 | Colin Barbera, FR, LB |
| 1986 | Rich Augsberger, SR, HB |
| 1985 | Maurice Webb, JR, LB |
| 1984 | Joe Whalen, SO, WR |
| 1983 | Vern Larson, JR, OT |
| 1982 | Scott Knous, SO, HB |
| 1981 | Brian Gleason, SO, End |
| 1980 | Dan O'Malley, JR, TE |
| 1979 | John Fedorik, SR, QB |